I have often argued what the
preferred life of a philosopher should be. Aristotle obliviously believes that
a true philosophers place is within society. Is this true? I would like to say
yes. The whole point of philosophy is for the good of mankind so what good are
the answers if not shared? Although I agree with the overall point of Aristotle
it isn’t without terms.
While
I do think that it is only within the confines of a society that a great
thinker can use their abilities I don’t think any thinker can reach their own
full potential without a period of separation. What do I mean by this? This
separation I speak of is a seclusion from ones peers leaving one the time to
contemplate and question. While being within a society may be the best uses of
ones skills in concentrated contemplation I think there is something to be said
for the unique opportunities and ideas the solitary lifestyle brings. With
alone time seems to come a kind of peace and calmness of ones mind that often
brings forth the most profound ideas. Socrates is well known for doing this
when he would simply “zone out” and go into deep thought. Albert Einstein is
also known for being so focused on his ideas he was able to disassociate
himself from the world.
For
me it is a combination of intellectual conversation and time for thought that
brings forth the best results. I am not saying that everyone should go to the
woods or beach because that is not obligatory for all. I am speaking of a mind
state, while some are able to go into deep thought in any atmosphere most
people require some kind of control in order to completely focus on the task at
hand. I do agree that philosophers must work from within a society but they
must also remember importance of being able to separate themselves from their
society and think from a rational point of view.
Take a look at Bryant's blog ya'll have a very similar intuition about the nature of philosophy though you are talking about two different philosophers.
ReplyDeleteI agree about the need for balance between solitude and engagement with others.
ReplyDelete