After spending
all day today sick I wrote more than a few blogs and the first I decided to put
up is my blog on the pupil of Empedocles, Gorgias. Born in 483 Gorgias is well
known for his metaphysical view that Nothing exist. He said that nothing exist
(A) and even if existence does it exist it is impossible to determine (B).
Lastly he says that even if it could be determined it could never be
communicated. This may be a reason that he proclaims that although there is a
such thing as right and wrong he believes in manipulation like many of the
Sophists. In a way Gorgias can be used as an exact example of everything bad
the Sophists have been accused of. He did not seem as worried about truth as he
was about winning an argument. Although he is not determined to be the inventor
of paradoxical language his "mastery" of it often leads historians to
believe that he in fact was its creator. I do not consider him a philosopher
but more a master of rhetoric who did as much if not more to hurt philosophy as
to improve it. I think this is why Plato to finds quarrel with Gorgias.
Although I do not agree with many of his writings and ideas, he is still
remembered and studied today because he did in fact have a great impact on the
minds of the men who would later change the world.
Very good Leo. One of your most focused blogs.
ReplyDeletegood reflections.
ReplyDeleteIt's really intriguing to think that there are people whose greatest contributions are being both famous and wrong enough to instigate others to writ against them: i.e. Hume > Kant and Hegel > Kierkegaard.
ReplyDelete